Canada okay with Israeli soldiers firing on unarmed Palestinian farmers, and us


*Palestinian farmland in the southeast, just over a few hundred of metres from the border with Israel.

February 3, 2009

I was fairly certain that one of us would be shot today.

This morning, farmers from Abassan Jadiida (New Abassan), to the east of Khan Younis , the southern region, returned to land they’d been forced off of during and following the war on Gaza. The continual shooting at them by Israeli soldiers while they work the land intensified post-war on Gaza. The Israeli soldiers’ shooting was not a new thing, but a resumption of the policy of harassment that Palestinians in the border areas have been enduring for years, a harassment extending to invasions in which agricultural land, chicken farms, and the houses in the region have been targeted, destroyed in many cases.

Today’s Abassan farmers wanted to harvest their parsley.

Yusef Abu Shaheen, whose land was being harvested, explained that over the course of the year he invests about $54,000 in planting, watering and maintenance of the monthly crops. From that investment, if all goes well and crops are harvested throughout the year, he can bring in about $10,000/month, meaning that he can pay off the investment and support the 15 families dependent on the harvest.

The work began shortly after 11 am, with the handful of farmers working swiftly, cutting swathes of tall parsley and bundling it as rapidly as it was cut. These bundles were then loaded onto a waiting donkey cart. The speed of the farmers was impressive, and one realized that were they able to work ‘normally’ as any farmer in unoccupied areas, they would be very productive. A lone donkey grazed in an area a little closer to the border fence. When asked if this was not dangerous for the donkey, the farmers replied that they had no other choice: with the borders closed, animal feed is starkly absent. The tragedy of having to worry about being shot once again struck me, as it did when harvesting olives or herding sheep with West Bank Palestinians who are routinely attacked by Israeli settlers and by the Israeli army as they try to work and live on their land.

After approximately 2 hours of harvesting, during which the sound of an F-16 overhead was accompanied by Israeli jeeps seen driving along the border area, with at least one stationed directly across from the area in question, Israeli soldiers began firing. At first the shots seemed like warning shots: sharp and intrusive cracks of gunfire. The men kept working, gathering parsley, bunching it, loading it, while the international human rights observers present spread out in a line, to ensure our visibility.

It would have been hard to miss or mistake us, with fluorescent yellow vests and visibly unarmed–our hands were in the air.

Via bullhorn, we re-iterated our presence to the soldiers, informing them we were all unarmed civilians, the farmers were rightfully working their land, the soldiers were being filmed by an Italian film crew. We also informed some of our embassies of the situation: “we are on Palestinian farmland and are being shot at by Israeli soldiers on the other side of the border fence.”

For a brief period the shots ceased. Then began anew, again seemingly warning shots, although this time visibly hitting dirt 15 and 20 m from us. Furthest to the south, I heard the whizz of bullets past my ear, though to estimate the proximity would be impossible.

As the cracks of gunfire rang more frequently and louder, the shots closer, those of the farmers who hadn’t already hit the ground did so, sprawling flat for cover. The international observers continued to stand, brightly visible, hands in the air, bullhorn repeating our message of unarmed presence. The shots continued, from the direction of 3 or 4 visible soldiers on a mound hundreds of metres from us. With only my glasses I could make out their shapes, uniforms, the jeep… Certainly with their military equipment they could make out our faces, empty hands, parsley-loaded cart…

There was no mistaking the situation or their intent: pure harassment.

As the farmers tried to leave with their donkey carts, the shots continued. The two carts were eventually able to make it away, down the ruddy lane, a lane eaten by tank and bulldozer tracks from the land invasion weeks before. Some of us accompanied the carts away, out of firing range, then returned. There were still farmers on the land and they needed to evacuate.

As we stood, again arms still raised, still empty-handed, still proclaiming thus, the Israeli soldiers’ shooting drew much nearer. Those whizzing rushes were more frequent and undeniably close to my head, our heads. The Italian film crew accompanying us did not stop filming, nor did some of us with video cameras.

We announced our intention to move away, the soldiers shot. We stood still, the soldiers shot. At one point I was certain one of the farmers would be killed, as he had hit the ground again but in his panic seemed to want to jump up and run. I urged him to stay flat, stay down, and with our urging he did. The idea was to move as a group, a mixture of the targeted Palestinian farmers and the brightly-noticeable international accompaniers. And so we did, but the shots continued, rapidly, hitting within metres of our feet, flying within metres of our heads.

I’m amazed no one was killed today, nor that limbs were not lost, maimed.

While we’d been on the land, Yusef had gone to one end, to collect valves from the broken irrigation piping. The pipes themselves had been destroyed by a pre-war on Gaza invasion. “The plants have not been watered since one week before the war,” he’d told us. He collected the parts, each valve valuable in a region whose borders are sealed and where replacement parts for everything one could need to replace are unattainable or grossly expensive.

He’d also told us of the chicks in the chicken farm who’d first been dying for want of chicken feed, and then been bulldozed when Israeli soldiers attacked the house and building they were in.

My embassy rang me up, after we’d managed to get away from the firing: “We’re told you are being shot at. Can you give us the precise location, and maybe a landmark, some notable building nearby.”

I told Heather about the half-demolished house to the south of where we had been, and that we were on Palestinian farmland. After some further questioning, it dawned on her that the shooting was coming from the Israeli side. “How do you know it is Israeli soldiers shooting at you?” she’d asked. I mentioned the 4 jeeps, the soldiers on the mound, the shots from the soldiers on the mound (I didn’t have time to go into past experiences with Israeli soldiers in this very area and a little further south, similar experience of farmers being fired upon while we accompanied them.).

Heather asked if the soldiers had stopped firing, to which I told her, ‘no, they kept firing when we attempted to move away, hands in the air. They fired as we stood still, hands in the air. ” She suggested these were ‘warning shots’ at which I pointed out that warning shots would generally be in the air or 10s of metres away. These were hitting and whizzing past within metres.

She had no further thoughts at time, but did call back minutes later with Jordie Elms, the Canadian attache in the Tel Aviv office, who informed us that “Israel has declared the 1 km area along the border to be a ‘closed military zone’.”

When I pointed out that Israel had no legal ability to do such, that this closure is arbitrary and illegal, and that the farmers being kept off of their land or the Palestinians whose homes have been demolished in tandem with this closure had no other options: they needed to work the land, live on it… Jordie had no thoughts. He did, however, add that humanitarian and aid workers need to “know the risk of being in a closed area”.

Meaning, apparently, that it is OK with Jordie that Israeli soldiers were firing on unarmed civilians, because Israeli authorities have arbitrarily declared an area out of their jurisdiction (because Israel is “not occupying Gaza” right?!) as a ‘closed area’.

Israel’s latest massacre of 1,400 Palestinians –most of whom were civilians –aside, Israel’s destruction of over 4,000 houses and 17,000 buildings aside, Israel’s cutting off and shutting down of the Gaza Strip since 2006 aside, life is pretty wretched for the farmers and civilians in the areas flanking the border with Israel.

Last week, the young man from Khan Younis who was shot while working on farmland in the “buffer zone” was actually on land near where we accompanied farmers today. Why do Israeli authorities think they have an uncontested right to allow/instruct their soldiers to shoot at Palestinian farmers trying to work their land?

If Israeli authorities recognized Palestinian farmers’ need to work the land, Palestinian civilians’ right to live in their homes, then they would not have arbitrarily imposed a 1 km ban on existence along the border, from north to south. What gives Israel the right to say that now the previously-imposed 300 m ban on valuable agricultural land next to the order extends to 1 full kilometre, and that this inherently gives Israel the right to have bulldozed 10s of houses in this “buffer zone” and ravaged the farmland with military bulldozers and tanks.

Nothing does.


26 thoughts on “Canada okay with Israeli soldiers firing on unarmed Palestinian farmers, and us

  1. hello, i have been following your reports closely since the airstrikes began. thank you so much for your articulate essays, for your photos, for working to bring people from around the world so much closer together. know that from seattle, wa, i send my care and that we are trying to ferment actions here that will support all of the brave work that you are doing in palestine.

    we’re putting on an event this sunday and i would very much like to share with attendees some of the testimonies you’ve gathered and the insights you’ve gleaned. i hope that this is okay!

  2. Just wonder, by the way, how the Canadian government would react if the US declared a 1 km exclusion zone along the US/CDN border and started shooting at any Canadian farmer “irresponsible” enough to go inside it. Hmm.

  3. Disappointing but not surprising in light of the federal government’s announced policy that the embassy seemed uninterested in hearing about Israeli harassment and even less inclined to respond to it.

  4. I,m so glad you are safe and sound…Israel has the “right ” because the rest of the world sits silently, and if anyone gets killed -well- its their own fault for being in a ‘military zone”If anyone questions that “right” they are accused of being anyi-semetic, friends of terrorists etc
    Now the Palestinians cant fish or farm without harrassment and actual death , the borders are still closed ..what can they do? They are expected to give up all resistance, recognise Israel and then they might get the borders opened (if Israel feels like it)
    Again , your testomony is needed , don,t let their deeds go unnoticed or unpunished!!

  5. Thank you for sharing this experience with us. Just goes to show, Israel is always above the law. And they wonder why Hamas continues to fire rockets? Get the hell out of Gaza and the resistance will stop!

  6. Your website is good but very hard to read as the print is very small. Please us larger font.

  7. Thank you for your report and for the work that you do. The complicity of the Canadian government in supporting the abuses of Israel is so deep. Each Canadian must do his or her share to expose these abuses of the human rights of Palestinians by Israel and speak out in their communities about Canadian govt support of occupation and oppression.

  8. […] on bishops’ visit to Gaza A Gazan feast!, with photos Seeing is not like hearing, with photos Shooting at Farmers, What Gives Israel the Right?, with photos From Beneath the Rubble, with photos Next Time it Will Hurt More, with photos Ezbet […]

  9. Just wanted to thankyou for the effort. I found the Youtube video to be shocking, I actually had to forward to the end as the gun sound was so frightening and I was expecting half of them not to be there anymore. I truly am in awe at their bravery.

  10. […] In Gaza läuft derzeit die Petersilienernte. Da Gaza nach wie vor durch die israelische Blockade von den Nahrungsmitteln der Welt abgeschnitten ist, ist die im Gazastreifen selbst vorhandene Landwirtschaft natürlich für das Überleben der Menschen dort sehr wichtig. Einfach ist die Ernte jedoch nicht, denn die zionistische Terrorbande macht sich regelmäßig einen Spaß daraus, auf die Arbeiter zu schießen. […]

  11. […] ingår beskjutningen i en medveten strategi? På Ingaza-bloggen publicerades nyligen uppgifter om att fyra palestinska bönder skjutits vid olika tillfällen. Här […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s